Finding Description
Based on interview and record review, the facility failed to ensure a resident was free from verbal and mental abuse by a staff member to where the resident exhibited behaviors such as irritability and verbal disappointment in response to the staff member's presence for 1 of 3 residents reviewed for abuse. (Resident D)Findings include:The clinical record for Resident D was reviewed on 8/11/25 at 11:27 a.m. His diagnoses included, but were not limited to, depression, anxiety, pseudobulbar affect, hemiplegia, and hemiparesis. The 6/24/25 Quarterly MDS (Minimum Data Set) assessment indicated he was moderately cognitively impaired. A care plan, last reviewed/revised 7/7/25, indicated his cognition level could fluctuate throughout the day. A care plan, last reviewed/revised 7/7/25, indicated he was at risk for signs and symptoms of anxiety, and could have episodes of uncontrolled outbursts. The goal was for him to not have increased signs and symptoms of anxiety or uncontrolled outbursts. Approaches were to encourage him to verbalize fears and anxiety, and to offer validation and reassurance, and to maintain a calm environment. A care plan, last reviewed/revised 7/7/25, indicated he had a diagnosis of pseudobulbar affect and was known to exhibit angry outbursts related to extreme irritability, low frustration tolerance and a history of quick temper. The goal was for him to accept staff redirection/reassurance when angry. Approaches were for staff to always approach him calmly and in a non-confrontational manner; for staff to approach him only one at a time and not in a group; for staff to give him space and time to calm; and for staff to quietly ask him to stop his behavior. On 8/12/25 at 11:15 a.m., the Administrator provided the investigative file into an incident that occurred between Resident D and the Maintenance Director on 7/10/25 at 12:15 p.m. The file included the 7/15/25 follow-up incident report, the documented 7/10/25 CNA (Certified Nurse Aide) 3 interview, the documented 7/10/25 SSD (Social Services Director) interview, the undated written SSD statement, the documented 7/10/25 Resident C interview, and the documented 7/10/25 Resident D interview. The 7/15/25 follow-up incident report, completed by the Administrator, indicated a resident reported concerns with a staff member using harsh tones. An investigation was started, and the Maintenance Director was suspended pending investigation. The follow-up section of the report indicated the investigation was completed. Resident and staff interviews were conducted with no concerns noted. Resident D showed no signs or symptoms of psychosocial distress and denied staff using harsh tones. The Maintenance Director returned to work. The 7/10/25 CNA 3 interview, documented by the Administrator and signed by CNA 3, indicated CNA 3 was at the nurse's station when she heard Resident D yelling. Resident D sounded angry. CNA 3 went to Resident D's room. Resident D was sitting on the side of his bed, crying. Resident D informed CNA 3 he wanted to lay down, so CNA 3 covered him up in bed. The Maintenance Director and the SSD walked into the room, and Resident D started attempting to get out of bed. The Maintenance Director was standing at the foot of Resident D's bed, pointing his finger at Resident D and saying, You don't talk to me like that, in a loud voice. An interview was conducted with CNA 3 on 8/11/25 at 4:22 p.m. She indicated she worked at the facility for about a year as a CNA. About a week before her scheduled last day at the facility, due to transferring to a sister facility, she was sitting at the nurse's station and heard Resident D yelling. He sounded upset, so she went to check on him. When she walked toward Resident D's room, she saw the Maintenance Director walking down the hallway. When she entered the room, Resident D was crying and really upset. She calmed him down by changing the subject, talked about a local NFL (National Football League) team, and covered him up in bed. Then the Maintenance Director and SSD walked into the room. Resident D immediately freaks out, went into fight or flight. She remembered the Maintenance Director saying to Resident D, You don't f****** talk to me like that, while standing at the end of Resident D's bed, pointing his finger at Resident D. It was like a Walmart video. People yelling and crazy. It gives me chills. There were five people in the room at the time, including CNA 3, Resident D, Resident C who was Resident D's roommate, The Maintenance Director, and the SSD. The SSD ended up taking the Maintenance Director out of the room, and she followed. CNA 3 explained to the Maintenance Director that Resident D was cognitively impaired, and that he couldn't correct someone who was cognitively impaired like that. After explaining this the Maintenance Director, the Maintenance Director acted as if he didn't care. The Maintenance Director was mad and brushed it off. Resident C informed her that all Resident D wanted was for the Maintenance Director to take his lunch tray. Resident D had only one hand and one leg that worked, so if he saw anyone being lazy, it kind of pisses him off. CNA 3 had Resident D laid down, covered up, and calmed down, but as soon as the Maintenance Director came in the room, Resident D pulled his blankets off immediately, and got himself to the side of his bed, like he was trying to get at the Maintenance Director. Resident D normally needed assistance to get to the side of the bed. I would absolutely describe what I saw as verbal abuse. CNA 3 informed the Administrator of what she witnessed.An interview was conducted with the Administrator on 8/12/25 at 11:56 a.m. The Administrator reviewed CNA 3's documented interview and indicated that was how she recalled the interview. CNA 3 did not inform her that the Maintenance Director cussed at Resident D. If she had, she would have put that in the statement.The 7/10/25 SSD interview, documented by the Administrator and the SSD, indicated the SSD and Maintenance Director went into Resident D's room, because the Maintenance Director wanted the SSD to talk to Resident D. After entering the room, Resident D told the Maintenance Director to get out of his room. The Maintenance Director told the SSD that Resident D was not going to talk to him that way. Resident D was trying to get out of his bed to get at the Maintenance Director. Resident D basically just told the Maintenance Director to get out of his room. The SSD, CNA 3, and the Maintenance Director all left the room. The SSD informed the DON (Director of Nursing,) the Administrator, and nurse on duty of what happened. The SSD checked back in on Resident D.An interview was conducted with the SSD on 8/12/25 at 9:19 a.m. He indicated he worked at the facility for three and a half years as the SSD and Marketing Director. He was let go about a week ago. On 7/10/25, he was walking down the hallway, when the Maintenance Director asked him to go into Resident D's room. As soon as the SSD and Maintenance Director walked into the room, Resident D was screaming, Get this guy out my room, referencing the Maintenance Director. CNA 3 was present in the room as well. The SSD and CNA 3 were trying to prevent Resident D from getting out of bed, because he can't walk. The Maintenance Director was saying, This is what I'm talking about. The SSD witnessed how the Maintenance Director raised his voice, saying you're not going to talk to me like that, being confrontational. It was getting louder and louder. The SSD did not hear the Maintenance Director curse, just had a tone to his voice. When the SSD and the Maintenance Director first came to the room, the Maintenance Director stayed by the door, but by the end of the incident, he was at the end of Resident D's bed. The SSD was in between the Maintenance Director and Resident D, who was red in the face. The Maintenance Director was pointing at Resident D, saying, Look, this is what I'm talking about. The SSD thought the Maintenance Director verbally abused Resident D, based on what he witnessed. Resident D was screaming at the top of his lungs, and the Maintenance Director was matching his energy. The SSD was trying to calm down both Resident D and the Maintenance Director and keep Resident D safe. This went on for like ten minutes. The SSD saw the Maintenance Director in the hallway prior to entering Resident D's room with him, so there was clearly something that happened before then. Eventually the Maintenance Director left the room. The SSD remained in the room for a bit, to try and assist with calming Resident D down. Resident C, Resident D's roommate, informed him Resident D and the Maintenance Director were jaw jacking, raising their voices. The SSD informed the nurse on duty, the DON at the time, and the Administrator. The SSD informed the Administrator there was craziness going on down there. The SSD went back to check on Resident D, and things had calmed down. The SSD interviewed residents for the investigation later on, including Resident C. Resident C informed him Resident D and the Maintenance Director were going back and forth. Resident D yelled at the Maintenance Director. Then the Maintenance Director yelled at Resident D. The SSD did not know why the Maintenance Director went back into the room a second time, because he would not have done that. The Maintenance Director was sent home during the investigation, then called and told to come back. The Administrator asked the SSD back into her office and asked him if he thought Resident D was abused. The SSD wrote a statement to say Resident D was abused. The Administrator questioned his written statement, because it said abuse, so he changed his statement to say Resident D was not abused. The SSD indicated you could tell by looking at the statement that he originally wrote abuse and changed it to was not abused. The undated written statement by the SSD indicated, I believe that [name of Maintenance Director] was being firm with resident that his speech and tone was not acceptable and brought me in to be witness but was not abusive. The words was not were squeezed in between the words but and abusive, in smaller writing with the word was on top of the word not. An interview was conducted with the Administrator on 8/12/25 at 11:56 a.m. She indicated the SSD wrote his statement at the same time she interviewed him on 7/10/25. She asked the SSD if he thought it was abusive, and the SSD told her no. She absolutely did not have the SSD change his statement to reflect it was not abusive. The 7/10/25 Resident C interview, documented by the Administrator, indicated the Maintenance Director brought lunch trays into their room. Resident D said he did not want it and to take it away. Resident D cussed at the Maintenance Director. The Maintenance Director said don't talk to me like that. Resident C did not feel like the Maintenance Director was abusive at all.An interview was conducted with Resident C on 8/11/25 at 1:20 p.m. He indicated he witnessed an incident between Resident D and the Maintenance Director last month. Resident D became snippy and curses at people, and he cursed at the Maintenance Director. The Maintenance Director got huffy, when he realized he couldn't win, and left to get the SSD. They all came back into their room with another staff member. The Maintenance Director pointed his finger at Resident D, while standing towards the end of Resident D's bed. The Maintenance Director was not abusive, but he did yell.An interview was conducted with the Maintenance Director on 8/11/25 at 1:38 p.m. He indicated when he brought Resident D his lunch tray, Resident D asked him to remove an inhaler from his room. He did not feel comfortable removing the medication, and informed Resident D of that. Only he, Resident D, and Resident C were present in the room when he delivered the lunch trays. Resident D told him to get the f*** out of there, so the Maintenance Director left to get the SSD to handle it. The Maintenance Director also went back into the room with the SSD, but eventually left. CNA 3 was also present in the room. The Maintenance Director indicated he did not yell at or raise his voice at Resident D. He only asked if Resident D would please not cuss at him. I did not point my finger at him at all. The reason he went back into the room with the SSD was to explain what was going on, so he would get full picture, and so that everyone was on the same page as to what was going on. He explained it in the room in front of Resident D. He'd been trained on abuse upon hire, in April 2025, and again after this incident. He was told he handled the situation appropriately, that he backed out of the situation, because he wasn't helping.An interview was conducted with Resident D on 8/11/25 at 1:25 p.m. He indicated he did not recall an incident with the Maintenance Director. The 7/10/25 interview with Resident D, documented by the Administrator, indicated she spoke with Resident D at length regarding the incident between Resident D and the Maintenance Director. Resident D denied that the Maintenance Director yelled at him. Using the reasonable person concept, Resident D had the potential to experience ongoing anxiety, fear, agitation, and verbal outbursts in regards to the allegation involving the Maintenance Director. An interview was conducted with the Administrator on 8/11/25 at 2:15 p.m. and 8/12/25 at 11:56 a.m. She indicated when she spoke with Resident D and Resident C, neither of them said anything happened, so she unsubstantiated the allegation of abuse. Resident C said it was not abusive in any way. The Maintenance Director was trying to talk to Resident D, but when Resident D was upset, you couldn't talk to him. The Maintenance Director, being a newer employee, didn't know that about Resident D. The Maintenance Director just needed to walk away, instead of continuing to try to explain. The Maintenance Director was in-serviced on abuse, zero tolerance, and better ways to handle resident behaviors. The Abuse Prohibition, Reporting, and Investigation policy was provided by the Administrator on 8/11/25 at 1:50 p.m. It indicated, It is the policy of [name of facility] to provide each resident with an environment that is free from abuse, neglect, or misappropriation of resident property, and exploitation. This includes but is not limited to verbal abuse, sexual abuse, physical abuse, mental abuse, corporal punishment, and involuntary seclusion.Willful, used in the definition of abuse, means the individual must have acted deliberately, not that the individual intended to inflict injury or harm.Verbal Abuse-The use of oral, written, and/or gestured language that willfully includes disparaging and derogatory terms to residents or their families or within their hearing distance, regardless of their age, ability to comprehend, or disability. This includes any episode of staff to resident.Mental Abuse-Verbal or nonverbal infliction of anguish, pain, or distress that results in psychological or emotional suffering. This includes any episode of staff to resident; and resident to resident if it appears to be willfully directed to a specific resident. Examples of mental abuse include but are not limited to: Harassing a resident.Yelling or hovering over a resident, with the intent to intimidate.This citation relates to Complaint 2568713. 3.1-27(a)(1)3.1-27(b)