Finding Description
Based on interviews and record review conducted during the Abbreviated survey (Complaint #NY00385514) the facility did not ensure that residents were free from abuse and mistreatment for one (1) (Resident #1) of three (3) residents reviewed. Specifically, Certified Nurse Aide #3 was witnessed to slap Resident #1's head during care.The finding is:The policy Abuse Prohibition revised 2/2023, documented residents have the right to be free from physical abuse and mistreatment. The facility will not condone any form of resident abuse.The policy and procedure Facility Incident/Abuse Investigation and Reporting revised 6/7/23, documented mistreatment means inappropriate treatment of a resident. Physical abuse includes, but is not limited to hitting, slapping, punching, biting, and kicking. Corporal punishment, which is physical punishment, is used as a means to correct or control behavior. The New York State Department of Health document titled Your Rights as a Nursing Home Resident in New York State revised 10/2022, documented as a resident you have the right to be free from abuse including verbal, sexual, mental and physical abuse.1.Resident #1 had diagnoses including dementia with severe agitation, polyosteoarthritis (multiple joints are affected by osteoarthritis (degenerative joint disease) and history of falls. The Minimum Data Set (a resident assessment tool) dated 6/5/25 documented Resident #1 rarely/never understood, rarely/never understands. No behaviors were exhibited. The comprehensive care plan revised on 6/24/25, documented Resident #1 had an alteration in their psychosocial well-being and cognitive loss. They had a potential for alteration in mood and behavior pattern/communication, at times had physical behaviors during care. Interventions included to establish trust with resident, monitor mood/behavior for changes, respond to behaviors with the following diversions/approaches: reassurance, staff supervision outside of room, family support, utilize mechanical support animal, sensory boards. The resident was care planned for 2 staff assist as needed if the resident was not cooperating during dressing. The facility incident report Physical Aggression Received, prepared by the Director of Nursing, dated 7/1/25 at 10:20 PM, documented Resident #1 was in bed being rolled to change clothing when Resident #1 bit the aide's right arm, not letting go. The aide reactively slapped Resident #1 on the top of their head. Predisposing physiological factors included: agitation, confusion, incontinence, and impaired memory. Review of the Facility Reported Incident received 7/2/25 at 11:23 AM, documented there was reasonable cause to believe that abuse, neglect or mistreatment occurred on 7/1/25 at 10:20 PM. Investigation findings documented the incident was witnessed, with reason to believe an aide slapped Resident #1 in the head while the aide was being bit. An investigation statement dated 7/1/25 at 10:30 PM, signed by Certified Nurse Aide #3, documented when they (Certified Nurse Aide #3 and #4) rolled Resident #1 towards the wall Resident #1 lifted their head to bite Certified Nurse Aide #3 on their right arm, as they had rolled Resident #1 to the wall. Certified Nurse Aide #3 documented they tapped Resident #3 on the head without realizing it because Resident #1 was not letting go.An investigation statement dated 7/1/25 at 10:20 PM, signed by Certified Nurse Aide #4 documented that after they (Certified Nurse Aide #3 and #4) started to roll Resident #1, Resident #1 started to get a little bit agitated. Certified Nurse Aide #3 was standing at Resident #1's head when Resident #1 bit Certified Nurse Aide #3's arm. Certified Nurse Aide #4 documented Certified Nurse Aide #3 stated I'm sorry, I'm sorry I shouldn't have hit you. The investigation summary dated 7/2/25 and signed by the Director of Nursing on 7/3/25, documented it was determined that no abuse occurred and there was no intent in harming Resident #1. The Director of Nursing documented the staff member (Certified Nurse Aide #3) had physical contact with Resident #1; however, it was not willful and was reactionary to the situation with no intent to injure Resident #1. During an interview on 7/8/25 at 1:06 PM, Resident #1's family member stated they were told that Resident #1 was tapped on the head. They stated they did not know if it was a hard tap or a soft tap, but that stuff should not happen in a nursing home. They stated if Resident #1 did bite, that they could not help it. Resident #1's family member stated they were not happy about the situation and whether it was meant or not, Resident #1 should not have been tapped on the head. During a telephone interview on 7/8/25 at 1:19 PM, Certified Nurse Aide #4 stated they assisted Certified Nurse Aide #3 with getting Resident #1 ready for bed. They stated Certified Nurse Aide #3 was at the head of the bed removing Resident #1's shirt and they were at the foot of the bed removing Resident #1's pants. They stated they heard Certified Nurse Aide #3 yell and witnessed, and heard Certified Nurse Aide #3 slap the left corner part of Resident #1's forehead and top head with their hand. They stated Certified Nurse Aide #3 knew what they did was wrong and immediately stated they should not have hit Resident #1. Certified Nurse Aide #4 stated they saw Certified Nurse Aide #3's arm in Resident #1's mouth. Certified Nurse Aide #4 felt that what they witnessed during care of Resident #1 was wrong and was physical abuse.During a telephone interview on 7/8/25 at 1:41 PM, Licensed Practical Nurse #2 stated Certified Nurse Aide #4 notified them after care of Resident #1 on 7/1/25 around 10:00 PM that Certified Nurse Aide #3 slapped Resident #1 on the face. They stated they asked Certified Nurse Aide #3 if they hit Resident #1 and Certified Nurse Aide #3 replied, they did not mean to, it was a reaction. Licensed Practical Nurse #2 stated when caring for residents with dementia you never knew what kind a behavior you will experience and that Certified Nurse Aide #3's reaction was not appropriate and a form of physical abuse. During a telephone interview on 7/8/25 at 1:54 PM, Licensed Practical Nurse #3 Supervisor stated they were notified at the end of the evening shift on 7/1/25 that Certified Nurse Aide #3 hit Resident #1 during care and that Certified Nurse Aide #3 was bit by Resident #1. They stated they called and notified the Director of Nursing of the abuse allegation. Licensed Practical Nurse #3 Supervisor stated abuse, slapping a resident, should not occur and that residents cannot protect themselves. During an interview on 7/8/25 at 2:45 PM, Certified Nurse Aide #3 stated during bedtime care of Resident #1 in bed, they were removing Resident #1's clothing and rolled them to their left side when Resident #1 leaned up and bit their right arm. Certified Nurse Aide #3 stated they tapped Resident #1's head with their left hand to get them off their arm. They stated they did not tap Resident #1 hard, that it was strictly a reaction because they were being bit and it hurt. They stated as soon as they tapped Resident #1, they should not have done that because it was wrong to hit residents. They stated, I know better. During interviews on 7/8/25 at 3:58 PM and 7/9/25 at 10:40 AM, the Administrator stated there was not intentional physical abuse of Resident #1 by Certified Nurse Aide #3. They stated the incident was reported to the Department of Health because it was an allegation of abuse. They stated under normal circumstances it would not be appropriate to slap a resident. The Administrator stated they would expect staff to remove their arm from a resident's mouth by pulling their arm away.During an interview on 7/9/25 at 11:02 AM, the Director of Nursing stated on 7/1/25 at about 10:45 PM Licensed Practical Nurse #3 Supervisor, along with Licensed Practical Nurse #2 notified them that while Certified Nurse Aides #3 and #4 provided care to Resident #1, Certified Nurse Aide #3 hit Resident #1 on the head in reaction to being bit by Resident #1. An examination was done on Resident #1 and no marks or injuries were observed. Certified Nurse Aide #3 was suspended pending investigation. They stated the allegation of abuse was verified by reviewing staff statements and looking at what qualified as abuse; it was reported to the Department of Health. They stated there was no intent determined, Certified Nurse Aide #3 did not think about it, they just reacted. The Director of Nursing stated they would not expect their staff to react like that. They expected staff to speak to the resident, suggest to resident to stop biting, or pull arm away from the resident's mouth. 10NYCRR 415.4(b)(1)(i)