Finding Description
**NOTE- TERMS IN BRACKETS HAVE BEEN EDITED TO PROTECT CONFIDENTIALITY** 4. Review of Resident #7's medical record revealed an initial admission date of 04/29/09. Diagnoses included end stage renal disease, anemia, anxiety disorder, history of a traumatic brain injury, bipolar disorder, paranoid schizophrenia, personality disorder, and mild cognitive impairment.
A plan of care initiated 05/06/09 indicated Resident #7 had the potential for impaired social interaction related to impaired cognition, insight, and judgment. Resident #7 had a tendency to keep to himself and pace hallways. Resident #7 exhibited mood states that were not easily altered. Interventions included allowing Resident #7 to wander freely within the unit/facility and to encourage self-control and problem solving.
A quarterly Minimum Data Set (MDS) assessment dated [DATE] indicated Resident #7 was able to make himself understood and was usually able to understand others. Resident #7 was assessed as having no short or long term memory problems and moderately impaired cognitive skills for daily decision making. Resident #7 had behavioral symptoms not directed toward others every day. Resident #7 walked in the corridor and in his room with supervision.
Review of a facility SRI revealed on 07/06/18 Resident #7 reported to staff that Resident #455 had attempted to strike out at him while in front of the nursing station. The investigation indicated during the investigation Resident #7 was unwilling to give more details and Resident #455 was unable to provide details. Both residents were placed on safety checks.
Review of the facility's investigation revealed Resident #146 was listed as a witness. The summary of the incident revealed Resident #146 reported Resident #455 was looking for a fight. There was no evidence Resident #146 was interviewed regarding what he meant when he stated Resident #455 was looking for a fight. There was no interview indicating Resident #146 was asked what he observed.
On 08/07/19 at 5:12 P.M., the Director of Nursing (DON) was interviewed regarding the incident that occurred on 07/06/18. The DON stated she recalled when Resident #146 stated Resident #455 was looking for a fight all Resident #455 did was enter Resident #7's room.
On 08/08/19 at 3:10 P.M., the DON was again interviewed regarding her statement that when Resident #146 reported Resident #455 was looking for fight it was because Resident #455 wandered into Resident #7's room. However, the investigation revealed the incident occurred in front of the nursing station. The DON verified the discrepancy. The DON verified she had not received clarification regarding what Resident #146 meant or what he observed. The DON verified with Resident #146 being the only witness, it would have been imperative to determine if something had precipitated the interaction in order to identify triggers and prevent possible further aggressive behaviors. When the DON was informed the investigation did not appear to be complete as was referred to in the abuse policy, she did not disagree.
5. Review of Resident #145's medical record revealed an initial admission date of 02/22/11. Diagnoses included dementia, unsteadiness on his feet, generalized muscle weakness, history of traumatic brain injury, anxiety disorder, schizoaffective disorder, borderline personality disorder, and psychosis.
An annual MDS assessment dated [DATE] indicated Resident #145 had unclear speech. Resident #145 was usually able to make himself understood and usually understood others. Resident #145 was assessed with short and long term memory problems and had moderately impaired cognitive skills for daily decision making. Resident #145 exhibited behavioral symptoms not directed toward others daily. The assessment indicated Resident #145's behaviors did not place him or others at risk. Resident #145 wandered daily but not to potentially dangerous places and wandering did not significantly intrude on the privacy or activities of others. Resident #145 required supervision while walking in the room and corridor.
A nursing note dated 03/18/19 at 6:15 P.M. indicated staff observed another resident holding onto Resident #145 at the waist on the floor. The other resident was striking out at Resident #145 and staff separated the residents.
Review of a facility SRI revealed on 03/18/19 staff observed Resident #455 holding onto Resident #145's waist and they were on the floor. The SRI indicated Resident #455 attempted to strike Resident #145. After being separated, Resident #455 wandered over to Resident #550 and put his arms around her waist while she was seated in her wheelchair. Staff immediately separated and redirected both residents. The SRI revealed Resident #550 stated she was alright and said Resident #455 was a confused man.
Review of the facility investigation of the incident did not include an interview from Resident #550 to determine what, if anything, she observed occur between Residents #145 and #455.
On 08/08/19 at 3:10 P.M., the DON verified Resident #550 had not been interviewed regarding the altercation between Residents #145 and #455. The DON was informed the investigation did not appear to be thorough as addressed in the facility's abuse policy without the interview of the possible witness. The DON indicated she had no additional information.
Review of the facility's Abuse, Neglect, Exploitation and Misappropriation of Resident Property, dated 11/21/16, revealed in the case of resident to resident abuse, the parties were separated from one another until the investigation was completed. The policy indicated all alleged violations involving abuse were to be thoroughly investigated.
Based on record review, self-reported incident (SRI) review and interview the facility failed to effectively implement their abuse abuse policy and procedure to prevent incidents of abuse and to ensure all allegations were thoroughly investigated. This affected five residents (#7, #52, #72, #106 and #145) of six residents reviewed for abuse.
Findings include:
1. Review of Resident #72's medical record revealed an admission date of 03/15/19 with diagnoses including diabetes, hypertension, vitamin D deficiency, anxiety, chronic pain, depression and dementia with behavioral disturbance. Review of a quarterly comprehensive Minimum Data Set (MDS) 3.0 assessment dated [DATE] revealed Resident #72 was cognitively impaired and required limited assistance for ambulation and dressing. A care plan for Resident #72 revealed he wandered into peer's rooms to take things that did not belong to him. Listed interventions included the resident was sent to the emergency room for medical evaluation (03/23/19) and a colored sign was placed on the door with name identification.
Review of nurses' notes from Resident #72's medical record dated 03/22/19 revealed the state tested nursing assistant (STNA) heard residents arguing in the hallway and upon coming into the hallway witnessed Resident #72 and Resident #151 striking at each other. Staff intervened and the residents were assessed. When asked, Resident #151 stated Resident #72 came into his room and grabbed his coffee so he struck him on the face. Resident #72 had red drainage coming from his nose. The doctor was notified, the family was attempted to be notified and Resident #72 was transferred to the emergency room. Resident #72 returned to the facility on [DATE]. Review of a nurse's note dated 03/23/19 revealed the family was reached and updated on Resident #72's condition which included a presumed nasal fracture; Augmentin (antibiotic) and follow up with an ear, nose, throat (ENT), physician specializing in care of the ears, nose and throat were ordered.
Review of emergency department paperwork dated 03/23/19 revealed Resident #72 had been treated for a presumed nasal fracture and was to follow up with an ENT.
Review of Resident #151's medical record revealed an admission date of 08/01/18 with diagnoses including prostate cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, hypertension, anxiety and insomnia. A discharge Minimum Data Set (MDS) 3.0 assessment dated [DATE] revealed Resident #151 had moderate cognitive impairment. Resident #151 was sent to the emergency room on [DATE] for shortness of breath and did not return to the facility. Care plans for Resident #151 revealed a history of false statements and physical aggression towards peers.
Review of a facility SRI dated 03/22/19 at 9:30 P.M. revealed an allegation of physical abuse between Resident #72 and Resident #151. Staff observed both residents arguing in the hallway and striking out at each other. The residents were separated and started on safety checks. Resident #151 stated Resident #72 came into his room and started drinking his coffee. Resident #72 did not provide any information. A brightly colored visual aid on Resident #72's doorway was placed as an intervention and Resident #151 was provided a room change. The facility found the allegation of physical abuse to be unsubstantiated.
Review of the facility's investigation dated 03/22/19 consisted of a single statement from State Tested Nursing Assistant (STNA) #502. STNA #502 stated he observed Resident #72 and Resident #151 arguing in Resident #151's room. Resident #72 swung out and Resident #151 attempted to deflect by swinging his arms. STNA #502 alerted Licensed Practical Nurse (LPN) #503. Resident #151 stated Resident #72 came into his room and was drinking his coffee. He wanted Resident #72 to leave his room but he swung out at him. Resident #72 did not add information. Notifications were made and Resident #151 was offered a room change. A brightly colored visual aid was placed on Resident #72's doorway to help him identify his own room. There was no information contained in the SRI or facility investigation that indicated Resident #72 had sustained injuries from the altercation and no additional witness statements from staff or residents were available for review.
Interview on 08/08/19 at 1:00 P.M. with the Director of Nursing (DON) revealed interviewing additional staff about residents' behavior prior to an incident was part of a thorough investigation and should have been completed. When asked about the incident dated 03/22/19, the DON verified the hitting between Resident #72 and Resident #151, as well as Resident #72's nosebleed and injuries should have been included in the SRI.
A follow-up interview on 08/08/19 at 3:07 P.M. with the DON verified Resident #72 did have blood coming from his nose as a result of the resident to resident altercation but did not know if Resident #72 or Resident #151 caused the bleeding as both residents' arms had been swinging around. The DON confirmed Resident #72 had a presumed nasal fracture per the emergency room report.
Review of additional information provided to the surveyor on 08/08/19 at 3:07 P.M. revealed communications with outside veteran services revealed Resident #72 was hit in the nose after taking a peer's coffee and his nose would not stop bleeding. He returned to the facility with an order to follow up with an ENT for possible nasal fracture and a computed tomography (CT- x-ray measurements from different angles which produce cross-sectional images of a specific area) scan was requested.
Review of a CT scan completed for Resident #72 on 04/04/19 revealed comminuted fractures in the bilateral nasal bones with three millimeters of displacement and rightward angulation of the fracture fragments.
Review of an outside provider consultation dated 04/03/19 revealed Resident #72 suffered nasal trauma on 03/23/19 during a peer to peer altercation at the facility. Resident #73 had a shifted nasal pyramid to the left. Surgery for closed reduction of Resident #72' s nose was scheduled for 04/08/19 and completed on that date. Review of a follow-up note dated 04/26/19 revealed Resident #72 was noncompliant with the nasal splints post surgery and pulled them out; more extensive surgical intervention would be required to correct the injury and Resident #72 was to be seen in four months for a follow-up.
A follow-up interview was conducted with the DON on 08/08/19 at 4:50 P.M. The surveyor again asked for LPN #503's written statement. The DON stated the SRI report was LPN #503's written statement and verified no additional documentation regarding the resident to resident incident was available for surveyor review.
A phone interview was conducted with LPN #503 on 08/08/19 at 6:46 P.M. LPN #503 verified her nurses' note from 03/22/19 and recalled Resident #72 and Resident #151 swinging their arms at each other. LPN #503 stated Resident #72's nose was swollen, didn't look right and had bloody drainage coming from it. LPN #503 shared she had documented in her nurses' note as well as completed a written statement regarding this resident to resident incident.
Review of the facility policy on Abuse, Neglect and Misappropriation dated 11/21/16 revealed it was facility policy to investigate all alleged violations involving abuse. Abuse was defined as the willful infliction of injury, unreasonable confinement, intimidation, or punishment with resulting physical harm, pain or mental anguish.
2. Review of Resident #106's medical record revealed an admission date of 09/11/15 with diagnoses including hypertension (high blood pressure), spinal stenosis, anxiety disorder, recurrent depressive disorders, psychosis, bipolar disorder, dysphagia, dementia with behavioral disturbance, noncompliance and chronic viral hepatitis C. Review of a quarterly MDS 3.0 comprehensive assessment dated [DATE] revealed Resident #106 had moderate cognitive impairment, had inattention behaviors, and had other behavioral symptoms not directed towards others four to six days in the review period.
Review of care plans for Resident #106 revealed a care plan for disturbing behavior, verbal and physical aggression and poor impulse control sometimes striking out at peers. Listed interventions included to attempt to identify what triggers behavior, discuss feelings of anger/guilt and options of appropriate channeling of these feelings with resident and educate resident on negative outcomes related to non-compliance.
Review of Resident #1's medical record revealed an admission date of 04/11/19 and diagnoses including vitamin D deficiency, dementia with behavioral disturbance, depressive disorder, schizophrenia and diabetes. A MDS 3.0 assessment dated [DATE] revealed Resident #1 was cognitively intact and had verbal behaviors one to three days in the review period.
A care plan for Resident #1 revealed the resident had dementia and behavioral symptoms. Listed interventions included being patient with the resident, monitor for signs and symptoms of frustration and take measures to remove these and provide cues or reminders and address concerns promptly.
Review of a facility SRI dated 06/10/19 at 5:30 P.M. revealed an allegation of physical abuse involving Resident #106 and Resident #1. Resident #106 was observed to be getting up the floor in the hallway and stated Resident #1 struck him, causing him to fall. Resident #1 alleged Resident #106 struck him then fell. Both residents were separated. The facility found the allegation to be unsubstantiated.
Review of the facility investigation documentation revealed no witnesses were present, safety checks were started, notifications were made and aggression risk assessments were completed. Resident #1 and Resident #106 were examined and interviewed. A single statement was included with the investigation from Registered Nurse (RN) #500 revealed she noted Resident #106 getting up off the floor and that he stated Resident #1 struck him on the face and he fell. Resident #1 stated Resident #106 had been standing next to him, told him to sit down and called him names, hit him in the face then fell. The residents were separated, both residents were noted to be confused. No other staff or resident statements were included with the facility's investigation.
Review of a nurses' note from Resident #106's medical record dated 06/10/19 at 5:30 P.M. revealed RN #500 noted Resident #106 getting up the floor of the hallway, agitated and arguing with his peer, Resident #1. When asked, Resident #106 stated Resident #1 struck him on the face and he fell. Resident #106 denied hitting Resident #1. Resident #106 was assessed, placed on 15-minute safety checks and the physician and family were notified.
Review of a nurse's note in Resident #1's medical record dated 06/11/19 revealed Resident #1 was agitated about having neurological checks done, stating he didn't hit me and I didn't hit him, we were just swinging our hands in the air, missing each other.
Interview on 08/08/19 at 1:00 P.M. with the Director of Nursing (DON) revealed interviewing staff about residents' behavior prior to an incident was part of a thorough investigation and acknowledged that should have been done with the investigation. When asked about the incident on 06/10/19, the DON stated Resident #1's comment about neither resident hitting each other could have been included with the facility investigation. The DON agreed as the incident occurred in the hallway, there could have been other witnesses to interview as part of a thorough investigation.
A follow-up interview on 08/08/19 at 3:07 P.M. with the DON verified there was no additional information for review regarding the SRI investigation on 06/10/19.
Review of the facility policy on Abuse, Neglect and Misappropriation dated 11/21/16 revealed it was facility policy to investigate all alleged violations involving abuse. The facility was to ensure all allegations were reported immediately to the Administrator and have evidence all alleged violations were thoroughly investigated. The policy did not clearly identify what constituted a thorough investigation and did not give extensive guidance on preventing and investigating resident to resident incidents.
3. Review of Resident #52' s medical record revealed an admission date of 01/30/18 with diagnoses including chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, dysphagia (difficulty swallowing), mild intellectual disabilities, noncompliance, unspecified mental disorder due to known physiological condition, bipolar disorder and paranoid schizophrenia. A quarterly MDS 3.0 comprehensive assessment dated [DATE] revealed Resident #52 had moderate cognitive impairment and wandered, had verbal and other behaviors not directed towards others on a daily basis.
A care plan for Resident #52 revealed the resident had cognitive impairment and required oversight, cues and assistance daily with noted behaviors including yelling out daily, pacing and verbal aggression. Listed interventions included monitoring for changes in cognition and monitor for signs and symptoms of frustration and take measures to remove these.
Review of Resident #108's medical record revealed an admission date of 04/23/13 and diagnoses including dysphagia (difficulty swallowing), impulse disorder, anxiety, diabetes and Parkinson's disease. A significant change MDS 3.0 assessment dated [DATE] indicated the resident was cognitively intact. Care plans revealed Resident #108 received Hospice services.
Review of a facility SRI dated 03/29/19 at 6:45 P.M. revealed an allegation of physical abuse involving Resident #52 and Resident #108. When Resident #52 was attempted to be interviewed, he stated, I don't want to talk about it. Resident #108 was interviewed and revealed Resident #52 kept turning the light on and off so he struck out at Resident #52. The facility determined the allegation to be unsubstantiated.
Review of the corresponding facility investigation revealed a single statement written by Licensed Practical Nurse (LPN) #501 dated 03/29/19. LPN #501 heard Resident #52 yelling, get him off of me as she turned from the medication cart and saw him in the doorway of his room and he left before she could enter the room. Resident #108 was sitting in his wheelchair next to Resident #52's bed. LPN #501 asked Resident #108 what happened and he stated Resident #52 wouldn't leave the light on and he said he punched his arm. LPN #501 attempted to interview Resident #52 and he stated, I don't want to talk about it, it's not worth it, and refused assessment. Both residents were started on 15-minute checks. No additional resident or staff statements were available for review as part of the facility's investigation.
A nurses' note from Resident #52's medical record dated 03/29/19 and written by LPN #501 revealed she heard Resident #52 yell, get him off of me and saw the resident in the doorway of his room but he left before she could enter. Resident #52 told staff he did not want to talk about it and it's not worth it. Resident #52 denied injury and refused assessment; notifications were made and 15 minute checks were initiated.
Interview on 08/08/19 at 1:00 P.M. with the Director of Nursing (DON) revealed interviewing staff about residents' behaviors prior to an incident was part of a thorough investigation and acknowledged that should have been done with the investigation. The DON agreed there could have been other witnesses to interview as part of a thorough investigation.
A follow-up interview on 08/08/19 at 3:07 P.M. with the DON verified there was no additional information for review regarding the SRI investigation on 03/29/19.
Review of the facility policy on Abuse, Neglect and Misappropriation dated 11/21/16 revealed it was facility policy to investigate all alleged violations involving abuse. The facility was to ensure all allegations were reported immediately to the Administrator and have evidence all alleged violations were thoroughly investigated. The policy did not clearly identify what constituted a thorough investigation and did not give extensive guidance on preventing and investigating resident to resident incidents.