Finding Description
**NOTE- TERMS IN BRACKETS HAVE BEEN EDITED TO PROTECT CONFIDENTIALITY** Based on review of the South Dakota Department of Health (SD DOH) complaint intake report review, interview, security video review, record review, and policy review, the provider failed to ensure one of one certified nursing assistant (D) safely transported one of one sampled resident (1) in her wheelchair who fell out of her wheelchair and fractured her hip.Findings include:1. Review of the 9/10/25 SD DOH complaint intake report revealed the provider and Adult Protective Services (APS) reported resident 1 fell from her wheelchair to the SD DOH.The SD DOH facility-reported incident (FRI), received on 8/30/25, indicated that on 8/29/25 at around 8:00 p.m., while certified nursing assistant (CNA) D was transporting two residents in their wheelchairs, resident 1's wheelchair brake caught on the activity room window frame. She fell out of her wheelchair and complained of pain in her right hip and right foot. Resident 1 was transported to the emergency department where it was confirmed that she fractured her right hip. The provider re-educated staff in regards to proper movement with wheelchairs.The APS report, received on 9/8/25, revealed that on 8/29/25, CNA D was transporting resident 1 and another resident in their wheelchairs to the designated smoking area. Resident 1 was ran into the wall which resulted in resident 1's right hip fracture. Four people lifted resident 1 up from the floor and threw her onto the gurney to be transported to the emergency department. Resident 1 had emergency surgery on 8/30/25 to correct the hip fracture. 2. Interview on 9/30/25 at 9:12 a.m. with resident 1 revealed that on 8/28/25, CNA D was pushing her and another resident at the same time out to the smoking area. Resident 1 felt that CNA D was not paying attention to where he was pushing her. Her wheelchair got too close to the wall of windows, and something caught on the window frame. She fell out of her wheelchair and as soon as I [resident 1] hit that wall, I felt my hip pop.Resident 1 said that CNA D attempted to pick her up from the floor, but she told him that she was in too much pain. She said that she was hollering. Once other staff arrived, they tried to pick her up off the floor to sit her in her wheelchair, but she was in too much pain to move. The ambulance was called. Two ambulance staff and two CNAs helped lift her onto the ambulance gurney.While at the hospital, it was confirmed that she had fractured her right hip. She had corrective surgery and was readmitted back to the nursing home. She explained that she had rheumatoid arthritis, a disease that affected her joints and caused contractures (permanent tightening of muscles or joints) in her hands and knees. The fall and hip fracture were painful, and she continued to experience pain in her hip after she returned to the nursing home.Since returning to the nursing home, she felt increased anxiety and wanted to talk with someone about her side of the story. She became tearful as she felt that no one wanted to talk to her about the accident. She confirmed she continued to go out to smoke every day. She had to close her eyes and tensed up as she was transported past the area where she fell, as she was fearful of falling again.She confirmed that CNA D still worked at the facility. She did not fear him. She did not feel like he did it on purpose and that it was an accident. She indicated that she was okay with CNA D continuing to help care for her. 3. Interviews with a random sample of residents throughout the facility confirmed no other concerns with staff providing their care. 4. Interview on 9/30/25 at 11:00 a.m. with licensed practical nurse (LPN) E revealed that she was a contracted travel nurse and had not heard about the above accident. She could not recall receiving any recent education about safe resident transporting expectations. She did not know where to find the provider's policy on what to do in the event of a resident fall, but she was able to verbalize understanding of the proper nursing procedures following a resident fall. When she started her contract at that facility, she received a week of mentored training to learn the normal facility routines and procedures. 5. Interview on 9/30/25 at 11:16 a.m. with CNA F and CNA K revealed that neither of them had been at the facility when the above accident happened, but they heard about it when they came back to work. They both confirmed that they did not receive any follow-up education about the fall policy or safe resident transporting expectations. CNA F indicated the report she received about the accident was more of an FYI [for your information]. Continued interview on 9/30/25 at 11:20 a.m. with CNA F individually revealed she heard that CNA D was pushing two residents in their wheelchairs at the same time. She indicated that was not the proper procedure and it was safer to push one resident at a time in a wheelchair. CNA F confirmed she knew where to find the facility policies and procedures regarding falls, accidents, and other topics. She was able to point out where the policies were located. 6. Interview on 9/30/25 at 11:39 a.m. with certified medication aide (CMA) G and CNA H revealed that neither of them was at the facility when the above accident occurred. They did not receive a briefing or report about the accident when they returned to work. They were not provided education recently about safe resident transportation. They learned about that accident from resident 1 when she returned from the hospital. 7. Review of the security camera footage on 9/30/25 at 12:17 p.m. with interim administrator A revealed that the accident occurred on 8/28/25 at around 7:25 p.m. CNA D was pushing two residents in their wheelchairs at the same time. He was pushing resident 1 with his right hand, and resident 2 with his left hand. Resident 1 was close to the wall of windows of the activity room, and it appeared that something on her wheelchair caught on the window as the wheelchair suddenly stopped, and resident 1 fell forward out of her wheelchair and landed on her right hip. CNA D attempted to catch her, but he did not make it to her in time.Several other staff attended to the scene immediately and registered nurse (RN) J began measuring resident 1's vital signs (measurements of the body's basic functions, such as temperature, blood pressure, pulse, and respiration rate). CNA D and another CNA brought the full body lift (a mechanical lift and sling used to lift a person's full body) near resident 1 and attempted to slide the lift sling underneath the resident. They were not able to as resident 1 was showing signs of pain.LPN I sat on the ground with resident 1 and waited with her for the emergency medical service (EMS) to arrive. Two EMS employees, CNA D, and LPN I helped to lift resident 1 from the ground onto the gurney. Resident 1 left the facility with the two EMS employees via ambulance. 8. Review of the provider's incident investigation documentation revealed that they interviewed all staff and all interviewable residents. Staff questions included Has anyone reported to you that they do not feel safe in the facility? Yes or No, Has anyone reported to you that they do not feel safe with their care team? Yes or No, Has any resident reported abuse, neglect, theft, mistreatment to you? Yes or No, and Who do you report abuse, neglect, theft, or mistreatment to?Resident interview questions included Do you feel safe in the facility? Yes or No. [If] no, why? Do you feel safe with your care team? Yes or No. [If] no, why? In the past week has anyone physically abused you? Yes or No, and In the past week has anyone mistreated you? Yes or No.Resident 1 was interviewed on 9/4/25 and answered Yes to the first and second resident questions regarding feeling safe, and No to the third and fourth resident questions regarding physical abuse and mistreatment.The investigation documentation included the SD DOH FRI, a letter to the SD DOH from administrator A that explained the provider's investigation process and included RN J and CNA D's witness statements, and CNA D's background check and training records from his contract staffing agency.The letter from administrator A to the SD DOH included the statement, In good faith effort the facility will provide education on how to push a wheelchair. There was no documentation provided to support who was educated, what the education topics included, or when the education occurred. 9. Review of resident 1's electronic medical record revealed that she was admitted on [DATE]. Her 6/23/25 Brief Interview for Mental Status score from her admission Minimum Data Set (MDS) assessment was 14, which indicated her cognition was intact. She had a diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis, which is a disease where the body's immune system mistakenly attacks the joints, causing pain, swelling, and stiffness in the joints. She had contractures in her knees and hands, and she could not bend or move her joints normally.Her current care plan indicated Locomotion: Her primary mode of transportation is via manual wheelchair. She is dependent on staff [assistance] of 1. D/T [Due to] her contracture she does refuse to utilize her foot pedals. Continually remind her to utilize the foot pedals. Foot pedals need to be on [when] going to appointments. That was initiated on 7/7/25 and revised on 9/26/25.A progress note from 8/29/25 read, Resident had a witnessed fall at 1925 [7:25 p.m.], after contacting Avel E-care for transport due to resident complaint of 10/10 right hip and right foot pain. Resident transported out of facility via [NAME] County ambulance to [provider name] ED [emergency department] per resident request at approximately 2005 [8:05 p.m.] this evening. This RN contacted [provider name] ED for [a] nurse-to-nurse report. Resident 1's primary care physician was contacted with the update.A progress note from 8/30/25 read, This RN received an update from [provider name] ED from Nurse [name redacted], resident is being admitted and results from the x-ray to the right hip show a fracture, currently waiting for results of the x-ray to right leg. Faxed MAR [medication administration record] to [provider name] Pharmacy. Resident gave this RN a verbal okay to sign bed hold and verbalized understanding of bed hold policy.Resident 1 returned to the facility on 9/3/25 after surgical repair of her hip. She returned with the following pain relief medication prescriptions:*Lidocaine patch (a pain relief patch applied to the skin). To be applied to the affected area and remain on for 12 hours, then taken off for 12 hours. That was to repeat for three days. Started on 9/13/25 and discontinued after 9/15/25.*Diclofenac (a pain relief medication) tablet, 75 mg (milligram). Give one tablet by mouth twice daily as needed. Started on 6/18/25. From 9/3/25 to 9/20/25, she used that medication 19 times.*Hydrocodone 5 mg (an opioid)/acetaminophen 325 mg (an analgesic pain relief medication) combination tablet. Give 1 tablet by mouth every eight hours as needed for pain. Started on 9/8/25. From 9/8/25 to 9/30/25, she had used that medication 43 times.*Hydromorphone 2 mg (an opioid) tablet. Give one tablet by mouth every four hours as needed for pain for up to five days. Started on 9/3/25 and discontinued on 9/8/25. During that time, she used that medication 18 times. 10. Phone interview on 9/30/25 at 3:01 p.m. with CNA D revealed that on 8/29/25 at around 7:25 p.m., he was taking two residents out to the smoking area. He was pushing residents 1 and 2 at the same time. Resident 1 was on his right side, and resident 2 was on his left side. As they were passing by the round activity room, part of resident 1's wheelchair caught on the wall of windows and she began to fall out of her wheelchair. I went to grab her to lower her to the floor. He called for help over the walkie talkies. Two other CNAs and two nurses responded to help.He indicated that he felt that they were short-handed that evening as he felt rushed to get his four residents out to their last smoke break for the day. One of the residents was feeling anxious to go outside, so he transported two residents at one time. He confirmed that he knew the general rule was to transport one resident at a time in their wheelchairs.After the incident, the nurse asked him to write down his statement. No one else interviewed him about the incident. He confirmed there was no disciplinary action, and there was no follow-up education provided. He was reassigned to the other unit for about a week or two after the incident but had since been reassigned back to resident 1's unit.He confirmed that when resident 1 returned to the facility, he went to apologize to her and said, I was at a loss for words. 11. Phone interview on 9/30/25 at 3:16 p.m. with LPN I revealed that he was resident 1's nurse that evening shift on 8/29/25. He did not witness the incident. He was preparing for the evening medication pass when CNA D was pushing residents 1 and 2 out to the smoking area. He said that I was not comfortable with him [CNA D] pushing two residents at the same time. He said that he expected staff push one resident at a time in their wheelchairs.He heard the commotion as she [resident 1] was in excruciating pain. She was yelling out in pain. He and another staff attempted to roll the full body lift sling underneath her to pick her up, but resident 1 was in too much pain to roll her on her side. They decided to leave her lying on her back until the EMS employees arrived.He confirmed that no one interviewed him about his involvement in the incident and that there was no follow-up education provided about resident safety protocols or policies. 12. Phone interview on 9/30/25 at 3:29 p.m. with CNA L revealed that she witnessed part of the incident. She was filling in for the front desk representative that day and she was delivering residents' packages. She saw CNA D pushing two residents at one time towards the smoking area. She confirmed that resident 1's wheelchair was close to the wall of windows. After resident 1 fell out of her wheelchair, she took charge of the other residents in the area and brought them to a safe location to give everyone else more room.She confirmed that no one had interviewed her about what she saw or her involvement in the incident, and there had been no follow-up education provided about resident safety. She said that she was a newer CNA and that some staff members told her it was okay to transport two residents at once, and others said that was not okay to do. 13. The survey team attempted to contact RN J on 9/30/25 at 3:38 p.m. via phone and left a voicemail. 14. Interview on 9/30/25 at 4:34 p.m. with interim administrator A and MDS coordinator B revealed that it was both their expectations that staff should push one wheelchair at a time. MDS coordinator B confirmed she was the interim director of nursing. They said that everyone should have foot pedals. Interim administrator A said that since she started a couple of months ago, she had noticed a lack of wheelchair foot pedals and was in the process of obtaining more.They both confirmed that resident 1 did not like the normal wheelchair foot pedals due to the contractures in her knees. With the way resident 1's legs were positioned, the standard wheelchair foot pedals were too far forward for her comfort.Their investigation included gathering a statement from CNA D and resident 1 about what had happened. MDS coordinator B confirmed that RN J spoke with CNA D and educated him on pushing one resident at a time in their wheelchair. 15. RN J returned the survey team's phone call on 9/30/25 at 6:08 p.m. That interview revealed that she was working on the green wing, and she was preparing to administer resident medications. She heard someone yelling, My hip! My hip!She went out of the green wing and saw resident 1 on the floor. CNA D told her that resident 1's wheelchair brake got caught on the side of the window panels. She measured the resident's vitals. Resident 1 was experiencing 10 out of 10 pain. They were attempting to use the full body lift to lift her up off the floor, but resident 1 was not able to tolerate that movement due to the pain. She contacted the on-call emergency medical provider, and they ordered for resident 1 to be assessed that the ED.She reported the incident to administrator A and the director of nursing. She instructed CNA D to write out a witness statement. She did not obtain witness statements from anyone else.She said that it was her expectation that staff transport one resident at a time in their wheelchairs. She confirmed that she provided education to CNA D to utilize the walkie talkies to ask for help, and to transport one resident at a time rather than two at a time. 16. Review of the provider's 1/22/23 FALLS-CLINICAL PROTOCOL policy revealed:* .3. Documentation-Responsible Parties:--Nursing staff--Physicians (if required)*3.1. Incident Documentation-Fall Report: Document the details of the fall, including:--Date, time, and location of the fall.--Circumstances leading to the fall.--Observations of the resident's condition immediately after the fall.--Any witnessed reports or bystanders.--Interventions provided immediately after the fall.* .5. Post-Fall Evaluation and Prevention-Responsible Parties:-Nursing staff-Social Worker or Care Coordinator-Physical Therapists (if applicable)-Physician (if applicable)*5.1. Reassess Fall Risk-.Update Care Plan: Adjust the care plan to address fall prevention strategies, such as:--Increased supervision or assistance with mobility.*5.2. Family and Resident Education-Family and Resident Discussion: Educate the resident and their family about the fall and the potential consequences. Discuss preventative measures that can be implemented moving forward.-Environmental Modifications: Ensure the resident's environment is safe (e.g., removing tripping hazards, ensuring good lighting, and using non-slip rugs).*The policy did not include staff education to prevent falls.